Horse Tack Review

Submit your reviews! We will be giving away a pair of the HandsOn Grooming Gloves for the best review posted from now until November 31st. Please read the November 1, 2016 newsletter for additional information on how to enter.

Professional's Choice
Charmayne James SMX Barrel Pad
Western Saddle Fittings/Pads

For Sale on eBay

For Sale on Amazon

Manufacturer: Professional's Choice (View all products by Professional's Choice)

Model: Charmayne James SMX Barrel Pad (View all Charmayne James SMX Barrel Pad reviews)

Category: Western Saddle Fittings/Pads

Purchase: I am just starting to get serious with pole bending with my horse so I was looking for a serious pad. I had seen good reviews in horse magazines about these which impressed me. I payed $87 for the pad because it was from the tack store where I work and I got the employee discount.

Likes: Well my horse did seem to move more freely, he is a gaited horse so I am pretty concerned with making sure his shoulder can rotate that way it is supposed to. It did leave nice even sweat lines.

Dislikes: I dislike too much about this pad considering what I paid. First of all I feel this pad is worth $40 tops, if you want to spend a lot of money on a pad, get something else. This pad also claims to have a 'lock down effect' to prevent rolling, not so I am afraid. I will admit that I am not very athletic when comes to mounting my horse, but this was quite ridiculous. As soon as I tried to swing my leg over the whole saddle would roll to the side and I mean REALLY roll. I had to have someone hold the saddle so I could get on. Once I finally got up there is seemed to stay in place ok, just make sure you get a leg up. I also thought this pad was going to be a miracle cure for Circle Y saddle that seems to be bothering my horse some how, again not so, so I am stuck using the crumby Wintec that for some reason my horse likes. Another thing about this pad is that it absolutely reeks like horse sweat even after you only use it once. I sure had to used a lot of Febreze to make that smell go away!

Quality: Not really sure yet. It seems ok, but I haven't used it much yet and do not intend to make this an everyday saddle pad either even when I am practicing poles. I will probably just use it at gymkhanas so I look in style. The Charmayne James lettering is already worn off and that was just from being in the store along time.

Summary: Over all, I will never buy one of these again and I even considered returning it, but it is probably a little too used now. I expected a better product from Professional's Choice considering how great their SMB boots are. So if you are looking for a good barrel pad for the serious gamer..this is not your pad. If you are just starting out in gaming and you have money burning a hole in your butt pocket then go for it.

Rating: 2

Author: The Tack Store Clerk

Date: 2007-10-07

Usefulness Rating: 2.30769 out of 5.
13 reader(s) voted.

Please give us your opinion..

Click Here To Submit Your Own Review

Other Reviews You May Find Interesting

Len Brown Turn n Burn Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
5 Star The Performer Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
SA Walls Slante Offset Barrel Racer Stirrups Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Classic Equine ESP Felt Top Pad - Round Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Saddleright Suede Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
SaddleRight, Inc. Orthopedic Competition Saddle Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Len Brown The Corrector Pad Turn N Burn Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Classic Equine Clinton Anderson PRS Saddle Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Classic equine / Clinton Anderson Prs saddle pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Bar J (Triple E Mfg) Contoured 3/4" Square Felt Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Weaver Leather Airflex Straight Cinch Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Impact Gel Western Coutour Barrel Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Diamond Wool Felt Barrel shaped Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Professional's Choice SMX AirRide All-Around Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
reinsman tacky too sway back pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Classic Equine CRCB / Blended Roper Cinch Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
BAR H EQUINE 25712 / Filigree Hair-On Tripping Collar Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
CSI Saddle Pads CSI Saddle Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Showman # TWR953 Trainer's Wither Relief Contoured Saddle Pad Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
Royal Mesa New Zealand Wool Show Blanket Western Saddle Fittings/Pads