Manufacturer: Kate's (View all products by Kate's Saddle Supply)
Model: Synthetic Marshal Poley (View all Synthetic Marshal Poley reviews)
Category: Trail Saddles
Purchase: Purchased from www.kates.net website. Got it on clearance for $229 (which was about $245 after shipping). Regular price is $359. I purchased the Synthetic Marshal Poley with the horn... It's a hybrid Western/Australian saddle with Western girthing and a Western horn but with Australian poleys for security.
Likes: I bought it because of the low price... But as I found out, that old saying is true -- you get what you pay for. I do like the people at Kate's... They're nice enough and provided good customer service. I just wish the product was better.
Dislikes: I was NOT at all impressed with the quality. Though I had "lowered expectations" to begin with since it had such a low price, I was still disappointed. The workmanship is poor. The saddle didn't correctly fit my horse. I sent in a wither tracing and was told they could fit a saddle to her, but it didn't work out... The tree "winged" out from her sides, and I was told that they couldn't do anything else to make it a better fit. Since I bought the saddle on clearance, I couldn't get a full refund on my money, either. Buying it was a big mistake.
Quality: The synthetic material is cheap and very poorly made. The fabric is *GLUED* onto the saddle, forming air bubbles and pockets where the nylon is pulling away from whatever material they use as a base. This problem only gets worse with time; ever little bend causes more bubbles in the material. Apparently, Kate's knew that the fabric was a problem with this model, but didn't warn me as a customer or offer to replace it as defective. The saddle looks just plain bad, and I doubt there'd be much of a resale market for this. The suede on the poleys was already looking bare and worn, and it was a brand new saddle.
Summary: I would strongly recommend avoiding this saddle. Perhaps their leather saddles would be better... I don't know. After seeing how poorly made the synthetic saddle is, I would be wary of purchasing another model from this manufacturer. Save your money -- get something better quality (like an Abetta synthetic -- a MUCH better saddle).
Usefulness Rating: 2.11111 out of 5.
9 reader(s) voted.
Pam's Place Tack Genado Gaited Trail Saddles
Circle y Alpine Trail Saddles
JC Martin Saddles Trail saddle Trail Saddles
Steele Saddle Mountaineer saddle Trail Saddles
TN Saddlery Sharptail Gaited Wsetern Saddle Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles Western Trail saddle, gaited tree Trail Saddles
Steve Edwards The Cowboy Trail Saddles
Dixieland Saddle Co. Tree style D +3/4 butterfly skirt light rider Trail Saddles
Bob Marshall Endurance Treeless Trail Saddles
Crestridge Wade Extra Wide Trail Saddles
Kimberley Kimberley Outback Australian Saddle Trail Saddles
Black Forest Saddles Rosewood treeless Trail Saddles
Crates #238-4 Trail Trail Saddles
Meleta Brown Freedom Saddle by Crates Crates Trail Meleta Brown Trail Saddles
Circle Y Kentucky Trail Gaiter Trail Saddles
Martin Saddlery Clinton Anderson Saddle Trail Saddles
J. Stead Wade Saddle Trail Saddles
Down Under Saddlery Kimberly Trail Master Trail Saddles
Tucker Tucker equitation endurance Trail Saddles
Tucker Endurance generation II Trail Saddles