Synthetic Marshal Poley
Trail Saddles

For Sale on eBay

Manufacturer: Kate's
Model: Synthetic Marshal Poley
Category: Trail Saddles

Purchase: Purchased from www.kates.net website. Got it on clearance for $229 (which was about $245 after shipping). Regular price is $359. I purchased the Synthetic Marshal Poley with the horn... It's a hybrid Western/Australian saddle with Western girthing and a Western horn but with Australian poleys for security.

Likes: I bought it because of the low price... But as I found out, that old saying is true -- you get what you pay for. I do like the people at Kate's... They're nice enough and provided good customer service. I just wish the product was better.

Dislikes: I was NOT at all impressed with the quality. Though I had "lowered expectations" to begin with since it had such a low price, I was still disappointed. The workmanship is poor. The saddle didn't correctly fit my horse. I sent in a wither tracing and was told they could fit a saddle to her, but it didn't work out... The tree "winged" out from her sides, and I was told that they couldn't do anything else to make it a better fit. Since I bought the saddle on clearance, I couldn't get a full refund on my money, either. Buying it was a big mistake.

Quality: The synthetic material is cheap and very poorly made. The fabric is *GLUED* onto the saddle, forming air bubbles and pockets where the nylon is pulling away from whatever material they use as a base. This problem only gets worse with time; ever little bend causes more bubbles in the material. Apparently, Kate's knew that the fabric was a problem with this model, but didn't warn me as a customer or offer to replace it as defective. The saddle looks just plain bad, and I doubt there'd be much of a resale market for this. The suede on the poleys was already looking bare and worn, and it was a brand new saddle.

Summary: I would strongly recommend avoiding this saddle. Perhaps their leather saddles would be better... I don't know. After seeing how poorly made the synthetic saddle is, I would be wary of purchasing another model from this manufacturer. Save your money -- get something better quality (like an Abetta synthetic -- a MUCH better saddle).

Rating: 2

Author: RedwoodRider

Date: 0000-00-00

Usefulness Rating: 2.5 out of 5.
6 reader(s) voted.

Please give us your opinion..

Other Reviews You May Find Interesting 

Martin Saddlery All Around Saddle Trail Saddles
Big. Horn Buckaroo. Flex saddle #1694 Trail Saddles
Fred Hook slick fork Trail Saddles
Tahoe Tack Tahoe Bad to the Bone Pleasure Trail Saddle Trail Saddles
Billy Cook 1779 Trail Saddles
Down Under Saddle Supply The Legend Australian Saddle Trail Saddles
Crest Ridge Saddlery Sinclair Lite Plantation Trail Saddle Trail Saddles
Sycamore Creek Saddles SSC005 Trail Saddles
Tennessean Endurance Trail Leather Saddle Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles Butterfly light rider wide tree Trail Saddles
rs saddlery training saddle Trail Saddles
High Horse by Circle Y Eldorado Trail Saddles
Sharon Saare Endurance/Trail Saddle Trail Saddles
Sommer saddle Spirit Trail Saddles
Brenda Imus 4 Beat Trail Saddles
Henry Miller Saddle Endurance 105 Trail Saddles
Wintec Pro Stock CS with Swinging Fenders Trail Saddles
Circle Y Just B Natural Treeless Saddle Trail Saddles
Tex Tan Tex Flex Live Oak Trail Saddle Trail Saddles
Circle P Leather All-Around Saddle Trail Saddles

2004-2012 Horse Tack Review

 Horse Tack Reviews
 Submit Your Own Review!
 Search Review Database
 All Reader Reviews
 Staff Reviews
 Submit a Product for Review

 English Tack Reviews
 Dressage Saddles
 Jumping Saddles
 Close Contact Saddles
 All Purpose Saddles
 English Saddle Fittings/Pads
 English Bridles
 English Bridle Accessories
 English Show Apparel
 English Casual Apparel
 English Chaps/Boots/Helmets
 English Miscellaneous

 Western Tack Reviews
 Barrel Saddles
 Reining Saddles
 Roping Saddles
 Show Saddles
 Trail Saddles
 Western Saddle Fittings/Pads
 Western Bridles
 Western Bridle Accessories
 Western Show Apparel
 Western Casual Apparel
 Western Chaps/Boots/Hats
 Western Miscellaneous

 Horse Gear Reviews
 Horse Boots and Wraps
 Horse Health and Well Being
 Horse Apparel
 Horse Treats
 Horse Miscellaneous

 Barn & Stable Reviews
 Fly Control
 Grooming Equipment
 Stable Accessories
 Tack Room
 Training Equipment
 Barn and Stable Misc

 Barn and Stable Articles
 English Articles
 Feature and Misc Articles
 Grooming Articles
 Horse Care & Health Articles
 Horse Related Gift Articles
 News and Events
 Training Articles
 Western Articles

 Other Features
 About Us / Contact Information
 Articles & Subjects By Date
 Article Archives
 Join Our Mailing List
 Privacy Policy