Manufacturer: Tad Coffin (View all products by Tad Coffin)
Model: A5 (View all A5 reviews)
Category: Jumping Saddles
Purchase: I tried this saddle from another girl at my barn, because we are roughly the same size and we both have long legs. I needed a new saddle because my old '93 Butet needed to be replaced. Even though the Tad Coffin was a 2001 saddle, I figured the brand was reputable enough to trust, not to mention the wear and tear was minimal. The owner was going to sell the saddle for $500 to get it off her hands (note: I didn't actually buy the saddle, read on to find out why!).
Likes: After being ridden in for years, it still looks great. The leather was high quality and the billets were still in good condition. I could move my leg freely, but I still felt secure -- what I wanted to change from my old Butet was the feeling of water-skiing, where my legs were in front of the vertical.
Dislikes: The saddle isn't too customizable (not that I took that route, but if I were going to, it's not available). The seat is flat as a pancake, which I personally don't like, and VERY hard, I felt like I was sitting on a slab of wood. That was definitely the deal breaker, because I want a comfortable saddle and something that doesn't distract me while I'm riding. The tree width is also an issue, because TC's only come in a wide style.
Quality: The seat, as I said, is flat-flat-flat. It doesn't make you slosh around the seat, but I personally don't like the flatness of it. The quality of the leather was great, though, especially for its age, and the color was still even, too.
Summary: I decided not to take this saddle, since it was just plain uncomfortable and the tree was a bit wide for my 16.2 Holsteiner. It fit me well and I was secure, but my comfort and my horse's comfort come first.
Usefulness Rating: 2.9 out of 5.
10 reader(s) voted.
Albion K2 jump saddle Jumping Saddles
Zaldi Top Jump Jumping Saddles
CWD Sellier Se01 CWD saddle Jumping Saddles
CWD CWD 2G hunter jumper saddle Jumping Saddles
Stubben Juventus S Jumping Saddles
Stubben S Get Connected Jumping Saddles
Cottage Craft Padded Jumping Saddle Jumping Saddles
Marcel Toulouse Stadia X/P Jumping Saddles
Albion K2 Jump Jumping Saddles
Heritage Bespoke Saddlery Kontact Jumping/Event Jumping Saddles
County Innovation Jumping Saddles
L'Apogee LXI Jumping Saddles
M. Toulouse Marielle Monoflap Jump Saddle Jumping Saddles
Devoucoux Socoa / calfskin Jumping Saddles
Antares Medium deep seat full calfskin Jumping Saddles
Tekna S line jumping saddle Jumping Saddles
Hastilow Hunter/Jumper Pony Saddle Jumping Saddles
Prestige Meridith Jumping Saddles
Heritage Bespoke Saddlery Kontact Monolite Jump/Event Saddle Jumping Saddles
Ideal Impala Monoflap Jumping Saddles