Horse Tack Review

Submit your reviews! We will be giving away a pair of the HandsOn Grooming Gloves for the best review posted from now until November 31st. Please read the November 1, 2016 newsletter for additional information on how to enter.

Caprilli with Cair
Dressage Saddles

For Sale on eBay

For Sale on Amazon

Manufacturer: Bates (View all products by Bates)

Model: Caprilli with Cair (View all Caprilli with Cair reviews)

Category: Dressage Saddles

Purchase: Purchased this saddle second hand from a private sale. Paid $1200 CA.

Likes: The look of the saddle is great and I find the seat comfortable (similar to a Stubben). Some riders find the seat too firm, but I found it to be a nice close contact, dressage seat. The price is reasonable and at first I liked the idea of the interchangeable gullet system.

Dislikes: Although this saddle is sold under the premise that it can be easily adjusted to fit a variety of horses, I found the opposite to be true. The gullet system really isn't ideal especially for an untrained eye for proper saddle fit. I found the saddle to bridge on some horses. I tried the saddle on 4 different horses of various body type and build and even though I adjusted the gullet according to the measurement guide and tool, the saddle did not fit, not even close. The other concern is that when the gullets are changed it really compromises the saddle. The leather can bump over the stirrup leathers, the twist becomes uncomfortable and the rider leg position is jeopardized, because there is now a huge wide seat to perch on.

Quality: The quality was satisfactory and the leather looked as though it would hold up. I have sold this saddle, so I am unsure how the leather will maintain. I am not a fan of any interchangeable gullet, the idea sounds great, but a professional fitter can't be replaced by a interchangeable gullet system alone. Good, well built saddles will fit a wide variety of horses and saddle pads can be placed to ensure optimum comfort.

Summary: The Bates saddle is a great looking saddle, with a nice seat (not overly stuffed or soft). They somewhat keep their resale. I do not like the gullet system and think that there will be a wide variety of horses out there that will suffer from a poorly fitted saddle, especially if the rider has bought into the philosophy of this saddle. Bates dealers will state that they can build up the saddle so that it fits smoothly under the saddle with no bridging, but in my opinion they are only guilty of adding another pressure point. Built up areas on the saddle will create a pressure area, because they are in place to provide depth under the saddle; this displaces the natural curve and I don't see how that could be anything, but problematic. If your horse just happens to fit nicely into the unmodified gullet (black), or smaller, than the saddle may work out well; But as for adjusting the gullets, the gullet is not the only area of concern when properly fitting a saddle.

Rating: 3

Author: Jen

Date: 2010-01-15

Usefulness Rating: 2.66667 out of 5.
12 reader(s) voted.

Please give us your opinion..

Click Here To Submit Your Own Review

Other Reviews You May Find Interesting

Tekna S-line Dressage saddle Dressage Saddles
MacRider Challenge Dressage Saddles
Custom Saddlery Steffen Peters Advantage Single Flap Dressage Saddles
double J Double J Pozzi Dressage Saddles
Freeform Treeless dressage Dressage Saddles
Thornhill Germania Klasse Saddle Dressage Saddles
Custom Saddlery Revolution Dressage Saddles
DK Saddlery Bond II and Freedom Dressage Saddles
Custom.Saddlery Revolution Revolution Dressage Saddles
Black Country Vinici X Monoflap Dressage Saddles
Zaldi dressage saddle Dressage Saddles
Kieffer Monarch dressage saddle Dressage Saddles
Erreplus Elena Dressage Saddles
Hermes Corlandus Dressage Saddles
County Connection Dressage Saddles
Karl Niedersuss Olympik Dressage Saddles
County Saddlery Fusion Dressage Saddles
Jeffries Elite Dressage Dressage Saddles
Philippe Fontaine by Stubben Orleans Junior Dressage, 16'' Dressage Saddles
Supra Synthetic Dressage Saddle Dressage Saddles