Horse Tack Review

Submit your reviews! We will be giving away a pair of the HandsOn Grooming Gloves for the best review posted from now until November 31st. Please read the November 1, 2016 newsletter for additional information on how to enter.

American Saddlery
Bear Trap Competitor Barrel Saddle
Barrel Saddles

For Sale on eBay

For Sale on Amazon

Manufacturer: American Saddlery (View all products by American Saddlery)

Model: Bear Trap Competitor Barrel Saddle (View all Bear Trap Competitor reviews)

Category: Barrel Saddles

Purchase: I purchased this saddle from and paid $599. I needed a secure western saddle for training my four year old 16h paint gelding. I looked at several different types of western/english saddles. I decided on this model because it's very well balanced, closer contact, high cantel, bear trap pommel, and not too heavy.

Likes: I really like this saddle. It's an excellent value for the price I paid. My horse has a lot of suspension like a warmblood horse, and this saddle keeps my butt in the saddle at the canter instead of slipping over the edge of the cantel. My horse is built slightly downhill as well, so I have a tendency to fall forward, but I can get leverage with my thighs using the pommels. These pommels will be a great help if my horse stumbles down a hill, and I have more leverage/security in case he spooks, bolts, or spins.

Dislikes: Like many less expensive western saddles, the seat does not have much padding, but I can fix this using a Cashel seat pad. If I could make a suggestion to the manufacturer it would be to use more padding and a heavier suede leather in the seat. I would gladly pay more for this feature.

Quality: Very good quality for the money paid. No defects and quality workmanship. Again, better suede leather and padding in the seat would be appreciated.

Summary: Very pleased with the saddle. It has all the features I need for training my young horse. Excellent value at a reasonable price.

Rating: 5

Author: Linda from Chaska, MN

Date: 2010-07-22

Usefulness Rating: 2.93333 out of 5.
15 reader(s) voted.

Please give us your opinion..

Click Here To Submit Your Own Review

Other Reviews You May Find Interesting

Dakota Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
HILASON HSTT801 Barrel Saddles
Dakota Barrel Saddle #345 Barrel Saddles
H&H 15 inch colored suede seat barrel saddle Barrel Saddles
Hilason Flex Tree Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
RS Saddlery Turquoise Seat rough out Barrel Saddle FQHB Barrel Saddles
frontier bobby stivers Barrel Saddles
Cactus Saddlery Charmayne James Barrel Saddles
Rocking T Saddlery Paul Humphrey Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
JC Martin 15" Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
RS Saddlery Turquoise Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
Madcow Skull Rider Barrel Saddles
Teskey's Custom (Buster Welch tree) Barrel Saddles
Tex Tan 1997 Hereford Barrel Saddles
Hilason Treeless Trail Riding/Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
Martin Barrel Racer Barrel racer Barrel Saddles
double t saddles barrel saddles Barrel Saddles
Double J Saddlery Pozzi Pro Racer (standard tree) Barrel Saddles
G - G barrel saddle Barrel saddle Barrel Saddles
Circle Y Just-be-natural barrel saddle Barrel Saddles