Manufacturer: Black Forest Saddles (View all products by Black Forest Saddles)
Model: Ponderosa Town and Country Echo (View all Ponderosa Town and Country Echo reviews)
Category: Trail Saddles
Purchase: Purchased from manufacturer at blackforestsaddles.com. Paid around $600 (excluding the pad). Communicated with the seller many times before purchase - including sending them lots of pictures of our horses. Felt they were honest and very very helpful.
Likes: It is like a good mattress: Proper and firm support for your body (as well as the horse's), but like soft memory foam at every pressure point. Contours to both partners perfectly. That comfort is great for long rides. Way better than any treed saddle I've ever had. Very lightweight. Amazing being able to carry around your own saddle with one arm without getting tired whatsoever - like carrying around a bareback pad, but one you can actually ride in and feel secure! I like that the stirrups are interchangeable, and the seat can be removed and cleaned. It's very versatile, and obvious some thought was put into the design. My horse actually started to relax the first time I put this on him. I hadn't seen that in 5 years.
Dislikes: I'm 130lbs, 5'3" girl. The measurements said I would be a "2". But 2 was way too big - more like a 16" western (or even 16.5" for a person at my weight. More weight makes the seat slightly deeper, so slightly smaller). Wish I had gotten the 1 instead, since that came with an interchangeable pommel too! Sucks that you you have to buy a treeless pad to go with it, because that can run $200. There are some on ebay that are cheaper, but I went with the higher quality on the same site. Nice pad works with all my saddles. As with any treeless, you need to mount from a step to prevent the saddle from sliding. I have mounted from the ground though without problems in this one. It's got a good shape. And as with any true treeless - the horn is not 100% functional - you can use it to safe yourself in a fall, but with that much stress it could rip (and you wouldn't want to use it for roping or anything like that).
Quality: The quality of the materials is very nice. Easy to clean and doesn't look like shirt material like cordura does. People mistake it for leather (except close up). Nice fleecing. Next time I buy a treeless, it will likely be a Black Forest. I'm just a light pleasure rider who goes on trail rides during the summer. My saddle is still in excellent condition. I'd recommend going with the leather for more frequent riding though, since these things really retain their value and the leather version will probably last forever so it's worth the extra cost.
Summary: Excellent value for the price, and good resale value. Worth considering over the pricier other quality brands.
Usefulness Rating: 2.875 out of 5.
8 reader(s) voted.
Simco "Deluxe" trail saddle 8695 Trail Saddles
Circle y Alabama trail gaitor Trail Saddles
Jason McKenzie 1 / Wade saddle Trail Saddles
Huber Training saddle Trail Saddles
Fabtron Easy Rider Trail Trail Saddles
CTK TASO 18 Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles Gaited wide tree Trail Saddles
ABETTA TRINITY SERENITY SYNTHETIC ENDURANCE SADDLE Trail Saddles
Wyoming Saddlery 16" Draft Custom Trail Saddles
DIXIELAND GAITED SADDLE Butterfly Skirt Roughout Trail Saddles
J. Stead Saddles.com Rose Wade Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles Butterfly Light Rider Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles LIGHT RIDER BUTTERFLY EXTRA WIDE GAITED FIT Trail Saddles
Sycamore Creek Sadles TASO 16 Trail Saddles
Dixieland Saddles Round Skirt Western Trail Trail Saddles
Dixieland Custom Butterfly Western Trail Saddle Trail Saddles
Leon Liversage Trailrider Trailrider Haboob Trail Saddles
Dixieland Saddles Custom made Endurance saddle with horn Trail Saddles
Mr. Saddle TReeless - Giraffe pattern Trail Saddles
Liberty Bell Leather Dakota 75 series gaited saddle Trail Saddles