Manufacturer: Collegiate (View all products by Collegiate)
Model: Monarch (View all Monarch reviews)
Category: Dressage Saddles
Purchase: I purchased this saddle used on ebay for $250 plus shipping.
Likes: After test riding an older consignment AP Collegiate ( which fit me like a glove, but not my horse)- I decided collegiate must be the saddle for me! Upon recept of this used 17" Collegiate Monarch dressage saddle, I was happy with the impeccable condition of the leather, despite its age. The leather was soft and with out cracks. I was also happy that the thigh/ Knee rolls were velcro adjustable. The spring tree is great and really makes for a nice ride. It was apparent with this saddle and the previous AP I had tested ,that my QH mare appreciates the freedom of movement provided by the Collegiate spring trees. Back to the leather- as acclaimed by Collegiate, the panels DO in fact allow for great contact , and form to your leg and the horses barrel.
Dislikes: After a few second in this saddle it was apparent it was NOT the ride for me. The seat was shallow and provided NO support for my bum. I found my hips being tilted back in a jumping position. When I attempted to canter I was tilled so oddly that I lost balance and felt as though I would slid off the back of the saddle. Like wise, I was completely prevented from bracing, driving or using my seat to support myself. I really like a tight deep seat- and this was NOT one. The day after my 1st & last ride in this thing , I placed the saddle on my local Craigs List for $200. A young lady purchased the saddle from me the next day, as she needed a dressage saddle for 3 day eventing. The girl text me the same evening that "the saddle rode weird, and did not fit her horse". (For the record I did offer her a chance to test ride in it). A few weeks later while shopping ebay, I noticed that very saddle on ebay for an opening bid of 99 cents. - NEED I SAY MORE.
Quality: BAD BAD BAD - dont bother with it- not for an extra -not for a 1st saddle -not for anything but leather or parts!!! Collegiate... what the heck were you thinking or drinking when you created this thing??? BTW- The AP I mentioned was fantastic though.
Usefulness Rating: 3 out of 5.
13 reader(s) voted.
Bond Street Pegasus Dressage Saddles
Cynron Pegasus Dressage Dressage Saddles
Hermes Corlandus Dressage Saddles
Rembrandt Integra - Non Adjustable Dressage Saddles
Prestige Venus K Dressage Saddles
Corta-flx Pellets 11lb size Dressage Saddles
Albion Revelation #87532 Dressage Saddles
Schleese Wave Dressage Saddles
County Saddlery County Perfection Dressage Saddles
Equipe Platinum Bocelli Dressage Saddles
Custom Saddlery Icon Flight Dressage Saddles
Collegiate 6521 / Monarch Dressage Saddles
Dixieland Saddlery Dixieland Butterfly Trail Saddle Dressage Saddles
Tudor Estate Dressage Saddle Dressage Saddles
Passier Dressage Saddle Corona Dressage Saddles
rocky creek hill flirt Dressage Saddles
County Saddlery Perfection saddle - New Zealand agent Dressage Saddles
Prestige 2000D Dressage Saddles
Passier Corona Dressage Saddles
Exselle Exselle Square Raised Bridle and Reins Dressage Saddles