Horse Tack Review

Submit your reviews! We will be giving away a pair of the HandsOn Grooming Gloves for the best review posted from now until November 31st. Please read the November 1, 2016 newsletter for additional information on how to enter.

Jumping Saddles

For Sale on eBay

For Sale on Amazon

Manufacturer: County (View all products by County Saddlery)

Model: Innovation (View all Innovation reviews)

Category: Jumping Saddles

Purchase: Purchased through local rep for Long Island, NY for $4,400 in 2010; purchased on recommendation of County customer and based on fit for my horse and my comfort during test.

Likes: It is very comfortable and initially fit my horse very well.

Dislikes: My saddle is black with the buffalo leather upgrade. Within a few months, every area exposed to light when riding faded to green. County replaced that saddle. The same thing happened to the next one, albeit over a longer period of time, but I decided to live with it. Additionally, the buffalo leather at the bottom of the skirt where the leathers touch has completely shredded away on both sides. This occurred a little over two years after I received the second saddle. When I reached out to County about this problem, pointing out that this same issue had happened to at least two other people in my area, I was told that County only occasionally had problems with inferior leather, so it was most likely the fault of my stirrup leathers (I ride in the softest Nunn Finer leathers). The best they would do was to give my half off the $750 repair cost; they did not offer me the use of a loaner during the repair which meant I would have nothing to ride in for the weeks it would take to fix. I recently reached out to our new local County rep, explaining the above, and have not heard anything in response. The saddle itself is also very dependent on refittings, which in my area cost around $200 a visit. Granted, it is used 5 days a week, but my horse is simply not changing his shape that quickly anymore. After spending over $4k on this saddle, I have since spent enough money on fittings that I could buy another saddle!

Quality: Generally, good construction except for the buffalo leather skirt cover piece, which as I noted above, has shredded completely. Poor quality tanning, at least for black, as it has faded to green on both of the County saddles I owned.

Summary: I paid way too much for my County saddle to have to put up with fading and shredding leather, and to have to further invest approximately $600 a year over the life of the saddle to maintain its fit. County's limited warranty indicates their reluctance to stand by their product and should be a red flag to purchasers. Their customer service is non-existent; again, you deserve much better after spending so much. If I had it to do all over again, I'd invest my money in a truly custom saddle or perhaps a Stubben.

Rating: 2

Author: Monique Anne Gaylor

Date: 2014-10-07

Usefulness Rating: 3.66667 out of 5.
51 reader(s) voted.

Please give us your opinion..

Click Here To Submit Your Own Review

Other Reviews You May Find Interesting

Courbette Husar Jumping Saddles
Stubben S Roxane Jumping Saddles
Zaldi Royal Event Jumping Saddles
Dark Horse Saddlery Dressage and Jump saddles Jumping Saddles
Zaldi Jump saddle Jumping Saddles
Zaldi jump saddle Jumping Saddles
Black Country Vinici Jump Jumping Saddles
Marcel Toulouse Legano Jumping Saddles
Thornhill Pro Trainer Le Monde Monoflap Saddle Jumping Saddles
Tekna S-line Jump Jumping Saddles
DG Stackhouse Custom Jumping saddle Jumping Saddles
Albion K2 jump saddle Jumping Saddles
Zaldi Top Jump Jumping Saddles
CWD Sellier Se01 CWD saddle Jumping Saddles
CWD CWD 2G hunter jumper saddle Jumping Saddles
Stubben Juventus S Jumping Saddles
Stubben S Get Connected Jumping Saddles
Cottage Craft Padded Jumping Saddle Jumping Saddles
Marcel Toulouse Stadia X/P Jumping Saddles
Albion K2 Jump Jumping Saddles