Manufacturer: Wintec (View all products by Wintec)
Model: Pro Elastic Dressage Girth (View all Pro Elastic Dressage Girth reviews)
Category: English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Purchase: Bought at local tack shop on sale. Needed a short dressage girth and liked the equisuede covering and non-chafe synthetic backing.
Likes: Very nice appearance, good roller buckles- overall, it is a sturdily constructed girth..
Dislikes: Whoever designed this thing didn't know what the heck he/she was doing.. Other reviews have noted that the Wintec girths don't seem to have any elastic in them despite the advertising claims.. Well, the thing *does* actually have an elastic in it (see details in the next section), but here's where the stupidity comes from: they effectively stitch down the ends of the elastic to the girth's synthetic covering, so in order for the elastic inside to stretch, first of all, the synthetic covering (faux suede covering and vinyl/neoprene backing) has to stretch, and unfortunately, these parts do not have any detectable stretch to them- I hung one end on a hook and attached 150lb of weights to the other end and there was no discernible elongation..
Quality: I run a saddlery repair shop on the side and I decided to open up the girth and see how it was put together inside and insert some real elastic. I found that they didn't lie completely and there actually *is* an elastic in the girth- the elastic is right in the middle of the girth (you can feel the more rigid section in the centre of the girth- that's the elastic). The elastic is connected via a wide nylon strap on each end to the buckles, which as I mentioned above, is stitched down to the synthetic girth covering, which does *NOT* stretch.. What I ended up doing was simply cutting the stitches that hold the buckles down to the girth covering (the buckles are independently sewn to the nylon web strap, so it's OK to cut the cover stitches). In this way, the elastic in the middle can now stretch independently of the covering material.. I went back to the tack shop and inspected all the other Wintec girth models and found the same idiotic construction- there is an elastic in the middle, but they basically stitch the ends down so that it can't stretch..
Summary: If you cut the stitches and allow the elastic to work, these are decent girths, but as-constructed, they are useless. I originally bought the girth 5 years ago, and I even sent an email to Bates informing them of this, but to this day, they have not changed the construction of their girths- the elastic is stitched down to the covering, which prevents it from actually stretching..
Author: Flying Dismount Saddlery Service
Usefulness Rating: 2.83333 out of 5.
18 reader(s) voted.
Ogilvy Memory Foam Jump Half Pad English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Prestige stirrup webbers English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Wembley Kwik-Out Stirrup irons English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Bevel Saddlery, LTD 4400002 / Double Elastic End Australian Nut Panel Girth English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Gatsby Adjustable English Girth English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Exselle Exselle Stirrup leathers English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Mikmar Le Tixerant Comfort Dressage Girth English Saddle Fittings/Pads
5 Star Dressage 1/2" wool felt saddle pad English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Ogilvy Ogilvy Jumper Memory Foam Half Pad English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Rittlings Sheepskin Full Pad English Saddle Fittings/Pads
K'Vall K'Vall stirrups and leathers English Saddle Fittings/Pads
MDC MDCUltimate Stirrup Irons English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Thorowgood Airoform Dressage/ Monoflap Girth (brown) English Saddle Fittings/Pads
CWD SA02C / CLASSIC GIRTH English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Barnsby Grip Pad English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Equine Comfort Products Classic Half Pad English Saddle Fittings/Pads
TREADSTONE 70010 / Soft Comfort Dressage Girth English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Union Hill LETTIA Collection Coolmax Lined Girth English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Korsteel Peacock stirrups English Saddle Fittings/Pads
Henri de Rivel Stirrup Leathers English Saddle Fittings/Pads