Manufacturer: Circle Y (View all products by Circle Y)
Model: Barrel Saddle 2033-2507-04 15" (View all Barrel Saddle 2033-2507-04 15\" reviews)
Category: Barrel Saddles
Purchase: I bought this saddle off Ebay for $736.00 shipping included. I heard Circle Y were excellent saddles and a review here on horsetackreview.com said that even for economy saddles, circle y was great.
Likes: I love this saddle. At first I was a little worried because some Circle y's sit smaller than the advertised seat size. This saddle has a 13" swell with a 4" cantle and fits like a dream. The seat is surprisingly comfy and the stirrups hang correctly under me. I like the light oil, roughout and black suede seat - it's very attractive and classy looking. It's a little larger for my horse than the American Saddlery Ekto One that I had (6 3/4 gullet for Circly and 6 1/4 for the Ekto)But she seems very comfortable. It has a special Effx Tree and lighter sheepskin on the underside which is supposed to form fit her better when she fills out. It's also super light. It comes with a nice warranty too.
Dislikes: I don't like how cheap the braided horn looks. It wasn't braided very tight so there are holes between a lot of the strips of rawhide. This is an economy saddle so there is less silver than their "Premium Economy" saddles. The stirrups are nylon under the roughout fenders which was not disclosed to me before I bought it. The rigging rubs my knee and gets uncomfortable after a while, next time I am going for the dropped rigging.
Quality: Some parts like the leather, seat, buckles, cantle, and tree are very well done. Since this is an economy saddle I think they skimped out on some of their usual top notch craftsmanship. The rawhide on the horn sucks, the nylon stirrups were a not so nice surprise, and the conchos look cheap. But like I said it's economy so you definitely get what you pay for.
Summary: I love this saddle for the price range I could afford. I love the Circl Y brand compared to all the other saddles I tried out. I know this should last for a long time.
Author: Kirby - St. Helens, OR
Usefulness Rating: 2.5 out of 5.
6 reader(s) voted.
RS Saddlery Turquoise Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
Madcow Skull Rider Barrel Saddles
Teskey's Custom (Buster Welch tree) Barrel Saddles
Tex Tan 1997 Hereford Barrel Saddles
Hilason Treeless Trail Riding/Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
Martin Barrel Racer Barrel racer Barrel Saddles
double t saddles barrel saddles Barrel Saddles
Double J Saddlery Pozzi Pro Racer (standard tree) Barrel Saddles
G - G barrel saddle Barrel saddle Barrel Saddles
Circle Y Just-be-natural barrel saddle Barrel Saddles
Griffith 1499 Barrel Saddles
Corriente Saddle Co N/A Barrel Saddles
Double TT Barrel Saddle 6568 Barrel Saddles
frontier saddlery Bobby Stivers Barrel Saddles
Double J Saddlery Pozzi Pro Barrel Saddles
Circle Y Flex 2 Kelly Kiminski barrel saddle Barrel Saddles
Martin Sherry Cervi Barrel Saddle Barrel Saddles
Shiloh Saddlery (Cecil Phillips) Ed Wright Barrel Saddles
Circle Y Bob Marshal Treeless Barrel Saddles
Double T Barrel saddle Barrel Saddles