Manufacturer: Bob Marshall
Model: Endurance saddle
Category: Trail Saddles
Purchase: I have an 50 mile Arab who always fussed about his saddle, ducked his head constantly, and usually had a sore back. When he started making saddle face too, I borrowed a friends Bob Marshall for a month to try it out. After a month's use, I bought it for $950, fully rigged. Thanks Pam!
Likes: As with all treeless saddles (that I've seen), the center line of the saddle is not raised at all, so an excellent blanket with pads is needed to keep the saddle off the spine. I use the Equipedic with one inch memory foam inserts, and it seems fine. I always ensure that the centers are aligned to keep the saddle off his spine.
Interestingly, there is NO slippage problem on the Arab, but there is some slippage on a much wider flatter horse that we tried it on. This horse is notorious for slippage, so its probably only an issue with the widest horses, or with heavy riders during mounting! I use a mounting block, but if forced to remount during the ride, have no problem (140 lbs).
I wondered if the saddle would be deep enough for me, as a deep saddle helps with the Arab tendency to shoot sideways at terrific speeds, but the saddle bends to conform to his back while in use, so it's actually deeper than it looks. Once I got used to it, I felt secure enough.
I tried another Bob Marshall endurance saddle briefly, and the stirrups felt like they were much too forward and swingy, so that is something to watch for. With this particular saddle, the stirrups seemed well placed for endurance.
My Arab prefers this saddle MUCH more than the other (a Wintec Pro Stock Aussie), and his jackhammer qualities softened noticeably with the treeless saddle. The other day, I used the old saddle on him, and the head ducking came right back. We went back to the treeless, and all is well. You can't argue with that!
Dislikes: This Bob Marshall is the endurance model and the leather is of good quality.
The rigging is Western with nylon straps, and my preference is for English rigging. I'm not overly fond of the stirrups, which (being Western) are not easy to adjust and also use nylon straps, rather than leather. The stirrup itself is plastic too, but is wide and deep and is comfortable enough for at least a 25 mile run.
Also, the leather flaps that cover the stirrups are not attractive, and don't match the rest of the saddle. They function well enough though, and I didn't buy it for its looks.
Summary: For the price, I was surprised to see so much nylon, but my horse prefers this saddle, and that means we'll keep it!
I would prefer raised pads under the saddle, so that it didn't sit on the spine, and better rigging, but the comfort is good for both of us. Ideally, I'd like one in equileather (like a Wintec), but the synthetic material may not give enough for a treeless saddle.
See if you can try one out before buying it. If your horse likes it, its probably worth buying!
Usefulness Rating: 3.31111 out of 5.
45 reader(s) voted.
Other Reviews You May Find Interesting
Circle Y Just B Natural Treeless Saddle Trail Saddles
Circle P Leather All-Around Saddle Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles 1 Butterfly/1 Endurance Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles English Plantation Trail Saddles
Allegany Mountain Trail Saddles Cascade Wade with gear Trail Saddles
Big Horn Cordura Trail Saddles
Freedom Saddle/Casa Dosa Freedom West Saddle Trail Saddles
James Saddlery Champion Cox Poley Australian Stock Saddle Trail Saddles
Imus 4 Beat Endurance with Fenders Trail Saddles
Fabtron 7152-F (B-Full QH Bars) Trail Saddles
Dixieland Endurance round skirt w/ horn flex tree Trail Saddles
Dixieland Gaited Saddles Light Rider Saddle Trail Saddles
JT international/ king series saddles old timer....but all apply Trail Saddles
Down Under Saddle Supply Kimberley Synthetic Stock SAD 280 Trail Saddles
Jay Bauman Buena Vista Trail Saddles
Abetta Round Skirt Trail Trail Saddles
Fabtron Cross Trail 7752S Trail Saddles
High Horse by Circle Y El Campo Gaited Trail Saddles
Buffalo 3458 western trail/pleasure saddle Trail Saddles
Dixieland gaited saddles The lite rider Trail Saddles